Are bagged vacuum cleaners better? Experts explain

No household is complete without a vacuum cleaner, and if you’re like many people, you’ve probably wondered whether bagged or bagless vacuum cleaners are the better option.

In recent years we have come across new and innovative models that promise to revolutionize cleaning. However, is there a common theme among some of the best vacuum cleaners on the market today? They are wireless And Bagless. But does that necessarily mean bagless is better?

While both types have their advantages, bagged vacuum cleaners have proven popular for a reason and even offer a few more advantages than their bagless counterparts. But, Are Is a vacuum cleaner with a bag better?

To finally settle the debate, we asked experts to break down the pros and cons of bagged and bagless vacuum cleaners to ultimately help you decide which option is better for your home and cleaning needs.

(Image credit: Getty Images)

Vacuum cleaner with bag: advantages and disadvantages

In general, if you are thinking about buying a bagged vacuum cleaner, there is a good chance that you are interested in it because it offers many hygienic and allergy-friendly benefits.

“Vacuum bags are designed to efficiently trap dust, dirt and allergens during cleaning. They contain special filter systems designed to capture even the smallest particles,” explains Paul Bagwell, founder of Halo. Typically these are HEPA filters. “By sealing dirt that contains bacteria, mold and other harmful microorganisms, individuals are not exposed to these pathogens,” he continues.

Empty the handheld vacuum cleaner bag into the container

(Image credit: Getty Images)

“The bags minimize contact with dust and dirt, which can be disposed of leaving as little mess as possible,” adds James Longley, managing director of Utility Bidder. So if you tend to vacuum when you have allergies, choosing a bag vacuum is a far more hygienic choice if you suffer from respiratory problems and the like.

Additionally, Emily Boulton, retail marketing manager at Numatic, points out that bagged vacuums protect the motor from dust, which in turn can extend the performance and lifespan of your vacuum. Therefore, you are less likely to notice signs that your vacuum cleaner needs to be replaced prematurely and more likely when the machine has actually been running well after frequent use.

Henry HV160 testing at home

A look inside a Henry vacuum cleaner bag

(Image credit: Future)

However, despite all the advantages of bagged vacuum cleaners, this does not mean that they do not also have disadvantages and nuances that need to be taken into account.

“Some vacuum cleaners don’t indicate when the bag is full, so it can be difficult to tell when it needs to be replaced.” They’re also not very environmentally friendly, because although the bags themselves are mostly made of paper, some materials contain, that cannot be recycled,” explains James. In addition, the cost of vacuum cleaner bags must of course also be taken into account, as vacuum cleaner bags should not be reused and maintenance is not for everyone when purchasing.

Of course, you should clean your vacuum cleaner regularly, regardless of whether it is bagged or bagless. However, if you choose the former, you need to make sure you can meet the maintenance requirements.

Vacuum cleaner bag on top of the vacuum cleaner unit

(Image credit: Getty Images)

Bagless vacuum cleaners: advantages and disadvantages

Since the early 2000s, bagless vacuums have been the preferred option for many households, and only a few brands – like the best Henry vacuums – stuck with their bagged models. The rise in popularity of bagless vacuum cleaners is thanks to Dyson, which introduced its first bagless vacuum cleaner in 1993 – and well, the rest is pretty much history from there.

Bagless vacuum cleaners have become the most sought-after type of vacuum cleaner alongside the best cordless vacuum cleaners for a very similar reason: their sheer convenience.

“Bagless vacuums offer the convenience of quick emptying without the need to purchase, insert and replace dust bags,” says Emily. Additionally, James points out that the clear chambers make it easy to see when they need to be emptied, are more environmentally friendly, and can be cheaper in the long run by eliminating the additional cost of purchasing bags.

Emptying the Dyson V8 Absolute into a trash bag in a trash can in a white room

Emptying a Dyson bagless vacuum cleaner

(Image credit: Future/Lauren Bradbury)

However, these very advantages are also their weak points. “They can be messy to empty and instead of bags, they have filters that need to be cleaned regularly to maintain performance,” counters Emily. With bagless vacuums, the likelihood of your vacuum losing suction power due to clogged filters and the like is much higher than with bagged vacuums.

When emptying bagless vacuum cleaners, you sometimes have to remove the remaining dust or dirt that has become trapped in the bin, unless the vacuum cleaner in question has a special system for trouble-free emptying, like many Dyson models or the Gtech AirRAM Platinum for example. But even then, there is still a risk of exposure to airborne dust particles.

“Alternatively, bagged vacuum cleaners, while filling the bags, provide a hygienic, dust-free emptying and trap dust and allergens,” adds Emily.

Empty vacuum cleaner trash can

(Image credit: Getty Images)

Buy a vacuum cleaner with a bag

Numatic Henry vacuum cleaner

Numatic Henry Xtra HVX200

Yes, you read that correctly. Henry offers a wireless model! This vacuum cleaner makes it easy to get quick jobs done and gives you fantastic suction power without sacrificing the biggest advantage of a Henry: dust-free emptying of the bag.

Although we haven’t tried and tested it ourselves yet, the Halo vacuum cleaners have received numerous positive reviews online from impressed customers. With a large bag volume of 2 liters, Halo promises optimal cleaning performance and allergy-friendly, dust-free emptying.

Which one should you choose?

With both arguments in mind, Are Is a vacuum cleaner with a bag better? In a way, yes. Although they are no longer the most popular choice these days and are sometimes associated with heavy-duty models like the iconic Henry vacuums, there are still lightweight and cordless bagged options. Knowing everything we do today, bag vacuum cleaners are definitely not as appreciated these days as they used to be.

Both bagged and bagless vacuum cleaners offer a solid mix of convenience and benefits – and which one you choose will depend on your personal needs and requirements based on your cleaning style.

If allergies and respiratory problems are a constant concern for you or the people in your household, choosing a bag vacuum cleaner can certainly be considered a clear decision as long as you are willing to meet the demands that come with replacing vacuum cleaner bags ( ( which is a lot easier than you might think) and buy them again. However, bagless vacuum cleaners are becoming increasingly popular for good reason and are considered the cheaper choice, so the choice is ultimately yours.

topicnews · September 27, 2024

Are bagged vacuum cleaners better? Experts explain

You may also like...

Recent Posts

topicnews · September 27, 2024

You may also like...

Swift hopes in vain: Sinner celebrates US Open title – Tennis News

CBI wants to bring out ‘absolute truth’ about RG Kar incident: SC

Europa-Park: Roller coaster passenger undergoes precautionary examination

Recent Posts